Try salmon fillet in a fancier salad.
Or you could go with shrimp and cocktail dipping sauce.
Chocolate covered strawberries are good too, aside from the seafood :)
I know you don't want deli sandwiches but what about some gourmet sandwiches. Grilled chicken wrap with micro greens and avocado. Or Grilled chicken and vegetables with pesto and in a ciabatta bun. Or some grilled salmon with roasted parisienne potatoes with olive oil and rosemary and grilled beans. Grilled Pesto Chicken on Penne Aliolio.
I'm surprising my boyfriend with a romantic picnic getaway for his birthday. I'm looking for something slightly elegant, not a cold deli sandwich. I know about the wine and cheese and am looking for more of main course ideas. Anything is appreciated though. Thanks. (: