Hello Z! Sargeant Carter would have Private Pyle in first class condition but he would have to talk Pyle into hiting Mr. Rodgers who is equally if not even nicer than Pyle. At the weigh in Mr. Rogers would ask Pyle is he would like to be his friend and of course Pyle would say yes much to the displeasure of Sargeant Carter. When the bell rings and they touch gloes, Mr. Rogers all of a sudden smacks Gomer with a solid shot which surprises him and right away Gomer realizes he's been double crossed and proceeds to chase Mr. Rogers around the ring. Pyle lands a couple of good shots here and there and cruises to the decision win.

Actually Jim Neibors is still alive and celebrated his 82nd birthday.I see Mr. Rogers entering the ring followed by The Muppets and his bodyguard Barney The Dinosour.. Gomer is followed by his bodyguards Andy Taylor and Barney Fife. The referee in charge is Floyd, The Barber. After receiving the referees instructions, Gomers chief trainer,Sgt. Vince Carter tells him: Move It! Move It! Move It!. Rogers trainer The Cookie Monster echoes the same words as Barney, the Dinosour,: I Love You, You Love Me.. Gomer tags Rogers with a gigantic Shazzzaam!, Rogers returns fire with: Its A Wonderful Day in The Neighborhood. They both fall to the canvas next to each other, look at each other. Both combatants begin to skip with each other and say to each other: Won't You Be My neighbor. But Gomer says: I am a neighbor. Rogers says: No Mas, No Mas. And Pyle says: Montreal ! Montreal ! Floyd raises Gomer's hand and Lou Ann gives him a great big smooch,Smack !

Mr. Rogers was in the Navy, before he found religion.

He always wore a sweater or long sleeves to cover his tattoos.

In a real fight, while they were both young Mr. Rogers would clean the pretend Marine Pyle's clock.

USMC Gomer Pyle would **** Mr. Rogers up. End of story.

Tough call, I heard the rumors about Fred Rogers being a Marine sniper, a Navy seal and doing three tours in Vietnam were all false. That being the case, the rumor that Jim Nabors was gay wasn't false, even if he never really married Rock Hudson, Nabors was one of Hollywoods most famous gay personalities. Call me a traditionalist but I gotta give the edge to Rodgers because he had a Mrs. Rogers who was female.

1) They aren't fighters!

2) How can they fight when they're both dead!

Gomer, from Andy Griffin, and Gomer Pyle USMC was one of the nicest, if not annoying, guys on TV. Mr. Rogers from Mr. Rogers' neighborhood, was one of the nicest guys, albeit a bit quirky, on TV.Who wins this battle?